Course management
Take one more club: why most amateur approach shots finish short
Shot-tracking data shows club golfers miss short far more often than long, and the trouble usually sits at the front. A simple back-of-the-green rule fixes it.
From 150 to 210 yards in the fairway, 72.7% of amateur approach shots finish short of the target and just 10% go long, according to Shot Scope.
Short from every distance, and from the rough
Shot Scope’s figures come from amateurs wearing its tracking devices. From 50 to 150 yards in the fairway, it found 40.4% of approaches finished short compared with 16.4% long. Over 150 yards the gap widens to the figures above. From the rough, the short misses climb further still.
Inside 150 yards, Shot Scope’s breakdown by direction shows the same bias. Short-left (17.4%) and short-right (19%) are both far more common than long-left (8%) and long-right (6.2%).
Architects put the trouble in front. In a separate analysis, Shot Scope reported that about 72% of the danger around greens sits at the front, against 28% at the back.
Why we come up short
- We club off our best shot, not our average one. The 7-iron you remember is the one you flushed. A slightly thin strike or contact off the heel costs yards, and those shots are part of your real distribution.
- Contact is rarely perfect. A strike off the centre of the face usually costs distance rather than adding it, so the misses cluster short.
- Conditions shorten shots. Cold air, damp turf, a lie in the rough and an uphill approach all take yards away.
- The flag pulls us in. We pick the club for the pin number. When the flag is at the front, that club is almost guaranteed to leave a large share of shots short of the green.
The back-of-the-green rule
Use this on every approach where the main trouble is short or in front:
- Get two numbers: the distance to the flag and the distance to the back edge of the green (most GPS devices and yardage books give front, middle and back).
- Use your average carry, not your best. If you don’t know it, a range session with a launch monitor or a few rounds on a tracking app will show you. Until then, assume it’s shorter than you think.
- Choose the club whose average carry lands between the flag and the back edge. With a front or middle flag, that often means one more club than your instinct says.
- Make your normal swing. Don’t take more club and then ease off it; the extra club is there so your usual, imperfect strike still finishes on the green.
Your good shots will finish past the flag, usually on the back half of the green. Your average and slightly poor shots, the ones that currently find the front bunker, will be on the putting surface. As Lou Stagner, data insights lead at Arccos Golf, put it in GOLF’s comparison of pros and amateurs, the aim for most club golfers from 100 yards is to hit the green anywhere and two-putt.
Water behind, steep greens and a long bias
- Trouble behind the green. Water, out of bounds or a steep drop at the back changes the maths. Pick the club that gets you to the middle and accept a longer first putt.
- Greens that slope hard from back to front. Past the flag can mean a fast downhill putt. On those greens, the middle is often the smarter number.
- Downwind, downhill or firm conditions. When the ball is releasing, carry to the middle and let it run.
- You already miss long. Some golfers, often better players with consistent strikes, do have a long bias. If your stats show that, trust them over the average.
When to ignore the flag, and when to track dispersion
Aiming to break 100. Ignore the flag almost entirely. Take enough club to reach the middle of the green with an ordinary strike, and when in doubt, take the longer club.
Handicaps of roughly 10 to 20. Shot Scope’s figures put a 10 handicap on about 35% of greens in regulation and a 15 handicap on 23%. Use the back-of-the-green rule on every approach over 130 yards and whenever there’s a front bunker in play.
Single-figure players. The step up is knowing your dispersion: how far short and long your shots with each club actually finish. Track it for a few rounds and pick targets that keep the whole pattern, not just the centre of it, away from trouble.
Count your short misses
Before every approach, say the back-of-the-green number out loud (or in your head) as well as the pin number. Then, on every shot where the danger is short, take the club that gets your average strike to the back half. Mark on your scorecard whether each approach finished short, pin-high or long. After 18 holes, count the marks. If most are still short, take one more club next time.
Sources
Spotted an error? Tell us and we will fix it. Our editorial standards.
